Fully Comprehensive Car Insurance

Compare fully comprehensive car insurance quotes

By Peter Carr Friday 25 May 2018

Fully comprehensive car insurance offers the most complete level of cover available – and it tends to be the cheapest, too. But not all policies are equal…

Group of young males and females enjoying car journey

What is comprehensive car insurance?

Comprehensive car insurance, also known as fully comp cover, is a type of policy that offers the highest level of cover. Fully comprehensive insurance provides protection for yourself, your vehicle, and for others, if you injure another person or damage another vehicle or property in an accident.

With fully comprehensive car insurance, your car is also insured against the following:

  • Fire
  • Theft/vandalism
  • Accidental damage
  • Loss of personal effects such as sat nav. Systems

It’s worth remembering, however, that although this type of insurance is called ‘fully comprehensive’, the name does not guarantee the quality of the policy. Always make sure you read the small print and are completely clear on what a policy gives you before you make a commitment.

Buying the correct insurance

It’s against the law to drive a car without motor insurance, but there are various levels of cover, so it’s worth finding out about the different types of policy on offer. You can then buy the right insurance for your car and your budget.

Car insurance prices have increased over the past few years. At the moment, full comprehensive insurance policies cost an average of £549.25 (as of January 2018), while just 5 years ago, the average was £456.93. That’s a whopping increase of 18.35%.

See how the cost of fully comprehensive car insurance has changed since 2013

MoneySuperMarket data, showing fully comprehensive car insurance quotes received in January of each year. Correct as of February 2018.

What does comprehensive insurance cover?

Third party insurance is the minimum legal requirement and provides cover if you cause damage or injury to another person, vehicle or property in a road accident.

Third party insurance is pretty basic in that it provides no cover for you or your vehicle, so you could opt instead for third party, fire and theft (TPF&T), which also covers your own vehicle if it is stolen or damaged in a fire.

But even TPF&T will not pay out for any damage to your own vehicle in an accident, which is why many people take out comprehensive, sometimes called fully comprehensive, insurance.

Comprehensive insurance covers third party, fire and theft, plus any damage to you or your own vehicle in an accident. Comprehensive policies also usually come with a range of additional features, such as:

  • European cover up to a certain number of days
  • Personal injury
  • Audio equipment
  • Personal belongings
  • Windscreen repair
  • Courtesy car

In some instances, these will be built into the policy itself, while in others you might have to pay an additional premium.

However, it’s important to bear in mind that no two policies are identical. If, for example, you intend to drive your car abroad, you should check the policy details to make sure you have appropriate cover.

Similarly, if not having access to a courtesy car is a deal breaker, read the small print before you sign up.


The difference between fully comprehensive, third party, fire & theft and third party car insurance

Why compare policy types?

Comprehensive insurance is no longer the more expensive option, even though it offers more generous cover. Third party only insurance and TPF&T is now, on average, more expensive than fully comp car insurance.

The reason for this is simple: people who take out third party insurance or TPF&T tend to be riskier drivers, and the cost of their claims pushes up the cost of premiums.

However, this is the average and not all drivers will necessarily get a cheaper full comprehensive policy, so it is therefore still a good idea to compare various types of policy. While you might be able to buy comprehensive cover for the same price or cheaper than third party insurance, it isn’t a guarantee.

There are particular demographics for which Third Party or TPF&T car insurance may still be cheaper. If you are a driver over 50 or have had five or more years with no claims, it’s definitely worth checking as you may find the cover cheaper than fully comprehensive.


The average fully comprehensive car insurance policy costs £549, which is much cheaper than third party, fire & theft at £858 and third party only at £1,293

MoneySuperMarket data, correct as of February 2018

Am I insured to drive any car?

Sometimes holding a fully comprehensive policy means you have insurance to drive any car, providing the registered owner gives permission. But before you jump in and try to drive any car, it’s important to note that insurance cover varies – so make sure you check your policy. And be aware that you might only have third party cover if you drive another car.

Cut the cost of cover

The cost of motor insurance varies according to a number of risk factors such as your age, experience and address. Basically, a 21-year-old who has been driving for two years and who lives in the inner city will pay more for cover than a 50-year-old with more than 30 years’ experience behind the wheel and a house in suburbia.  

There are a number of ways to save money on your car insurance quote:

  • Avoid claiming: If you don’t claim on your insurance, you are usually rewarded with a discount. The size of the discount varies from insurer to insurer, but you could knock 70% or more off the cost of cover if you don’t claim for five consecutive years.

It’s therefore a good idea to pay for any minor damage out of your own pocket to preserve your claim-free record.

  • Increase the excess: All motor insurance policies come with a compulsory excess, which is the amount you have to pay towards any claim. For example, if you put in a claim for £500 and the compulsory excess is £200, the insurer will pay out only £300.

Policies also have a voluntary excess, which can be used to lower the premium. You might for example agree to a voluntary excess of £100. Combined with the £200 compulsory excess mentioned above, you would therefore have to pay the first £300 of any claim you made.

You should make sure that whatever total excess you arrange is affordable, and most insurers will only accept voluntary excesses up to a certain level.

  • Limit your mileage: The more miles you drive, the more likely you are to have an accident and make a claim. So, if you are prepared to limit your mileage you should pay less for cover. Just make sure you agree a realistic annual mileage because you could invalidate the policy if you breach the limit.
  • Choose your car carefully: Insurers assign cars into 50 groups according to various factors including their engine performance and likely cost of repairs and parts. On a sliding scale, cars in low-numbered groups are cheaper to insure than cars in groups with higher numbers, with group 50 cars having the highest premiums (all other things being equal).

This means it’s worth checking out a car’s group rating before you buy. Also, try to resist modifying your vehicle because insurers tend to bump up premiums for modified cars.

  • Stick to the rules of the road: If you have any driving convictions, your insurance costs will accelerate. Penalty points on your licence also mean higher premiums. So, drive carefully and abide by the rules of the road.
  • Keep your car safe: If possible, keep your car in a locked garage overnight, or at least on a drive way. You will pay more for your insurance if your car is parked on the street when it’s not in use.
  • Try telematics insurance: Also known as black box insurance, the insurer will fit a box on to your car which then send information on your driving abilities wirelessly to the insurer. This can save younger drivers up to £202 a year on their premiums.
  • Compare premiums: Many people stick with the same insurer year after year, but loyalty rarely pays. You could save hundreds of pounds on your motor insurance premium if you compare prices across the market. It’s also quick and easy with MoneySuperMarket’s free, car insurance comparison service.


If you have more than five years no claims, or you’re a female aged over 40 or a male aged over 50, fully comprehensive insurance may not be the cheapest option.

MoneySuperMarket data, correct as of February 2018


Did you find this helpful? Why not share this article?

Our top car insurance articles


View all articles >

Popular car insurance guides


View all guides >